About Bokamoso Leadership Forum

Bokamoso Leadership Forum seeks to groom Africa's emerging leaders apt to face Africa's challenges of the 21st century and committed to pushing forward her development agenda.

Get The Latest News

Sign up to receive latest news

Disclaimer

As there are different authors for the articles on this blog, each article does not necessarily reflect the views of the Bokamoso Leadership Forum.

Share this content

Showing posts with label Topic of the Week. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Topic of the Week. Show all posts

09 November 2009

The Mo Ibrahim Prize: ‘Africa’ should be the winner


by Halif Sarki, a graduate Student at University of South Africa

The Mo-Ibrahim prize for good governance on the African continent has not been awarded this year as the Prize Committee could not reportedly “select a winner”. The Ibrahim prize is awarded after a ‘thorough’ examination, by the Prize Committee, of the prospective candidates through the microscope of an array of criteria including being democratically elected; serving within constitutional limits; and having left office in the last three years. Other key criterion includes the candidate’s contribution towards peace, security and development; and the promotion of democratic values and institutions. Does this then mean that good African leaders are hard to come by? Even more critical, what are the implications for freedom and the rule of law in Africa?

The Prize Committee is comprised of internationally respected figures such as, among others, Mohamed Elbaradei, Director of the International Atomic Energy Agency (AIEA), the former Organisation of African Union Secretary General Salim Ahmed Salim, the former Finnish president, Marti Ahtisaari and Former United Nations Secretary General, Kofi Anan who also chairs the committee. The laureate chosen by the committee is to receive a hefty ‘cheque’ of US$5 million over ten years with an additional US$200,000 per year for life thereafter. Since the establishment of the Mo-Ibrahim foundation in 2006, the selection committee has never failed to announce a winner. Previous recipients include former Presidents Joachim Chissano from Mozambique (2007), Festus Mogae from Botswana (2008), as well as Nelson Mandela from South Africa who was an honorary recipient in 2007.

The question on everyone’s lips when the prize could not be attributed this year was obviously, ‘why?’ thus entrenching the feeling that there must be a few former presidents on the African continent who objectively deserve the illustrious distinction. From the top of the head one could nominate, as potential laureates, former South African President Thabo Mbeki or former Ghanaian President John Kufuor or even former Nigerian President Olusegun Obasanjo for their commendable achievements in their respective countries and in Africa at large. Some would add to those three the likes of Ahmed Tejan Kabbah from Sierra Leone or Mathieu Kerekou from Benin. All five potential candidates seem to meet the preliminary criteria as they were all democratically elected; all served within constitutional term limits; and all left power in the last three years. So what is to be understood in the non-attribution of the prize this year? The ‘why’ question still lingers even weeks after the decision was announced as there has not been an official explanation given. 

Since the exhaustive list of criteria used by the Prize Committee remains elusive, one cannot fully and accurately analyse the selection of a particular candidate or, in this instance, the selection of no candidate. This, however, should not undermine the integrity or objectiveness of the committee but rather encourage the latter to maintain its purportedly high standards for assessing African leaders.

 The choice not to award the prize could therefore point to a deteriorating quality of leadership in Africa.  We can submit that the recent spite of unconstitutional transfer of power in Madagascar, Mauritania, and Guinea as well as the disregard for the constitution in Niger and Zimbabwe seriously tarnishes Africa’s remarkable progress on the path of freedom and the rule of law. Even then Africa’s democratic evolution remains appealing. African leaders now tend to use constitutional means to legitimise their rule. This is a considerable leap from the total autocratic rule of the early postcolonial years. One should bear in mind that it took centuries of wars and reforms to arrive at the ‘polished’ western model of democracy that we know.

Yet, I will argue that the selection criteria should be weighed against the structural and systemic challenges faced by African leaders, and the consistent democratic progress on the continent since the early 1990s. In that case one would certainly have to recognise that leadership in Africa has substantially improved and that such improvements should be acknowledged. If still no suitable candidate, then one could humbly suggest that the selection be widened to include civil society and other non-governmental organisations (NGOs) as well as individuals whose efforts undeniably contribute to the socio-economic development of the African continent. The recent granting of the Right livelihood award or more commonly known as the Alternative Nobel to the Congolese Rene Ngongo of Greenpeace prize is one such example.  The award in itself demonstrates that no one prize can fully satisfy the need to reward the many individuals who contribute to development. Furthermore, it demonstrates that there are Africans, not only Presidents, capable of good leadership.

Africa still has a long way to go and positive efforts along the road should be acknowledged rather than painting the whole continent with the same brush of failure. For a continent faced with many challenges, the call for good leadership remains critical in all sectors. Whilst Presidents are the head, we cannot deny the importance of the rest of the body.  Those answering the call for good leadership must be acknowledged beyond the state houses. 
»»  read more

24 August 2009

In Semenya's shoes: The deconstruction and reconstruction of gender and sexuality

by Bose Maposa and Siphokazi Magadla


For any track and field athlete, the World Championships are the main event, the center stage to prove their worth in the world league and claim their place amongst the greatest. Qualifying to attend these games is an honor in itself; winning a medal a glory; whilst a gold medal is the ultimate dream. One cannot begin to imagine what this could mean for an 18 year old first timer. But for Caster Semenya, the South African teenager who has emerged into the international headlines for breaking the 800m running world record this monumental moment has been overshadowed by the international outcry she has caused. The Semenya 'saga' has forced even those who do not care much for sports to pick sides (with her or the International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF)) after she was asked by the athletics body to undergo a gender test.

She has received different names and caused varied reactions, from '
Ms/Mr Semenya' in an attempt to ridicule her to 'Yes indeed she is a woman, but maybe an ugly one' in attempt to defend her. Some have even swayed from discussing the gold medalist and turned to talking more about the performance of her runner-up in the finals. Some have accused South Africans and other Africans who have come to her defense as blindly nationalistic or as Marx said under the spell of 'false consciousnesses'. While others maintain that the teenager is innocent until proven guilty, or that she remains sexless until proven otherwise, a game of cat and mouse but with no finish line is in sight. Amongst other things, she has highlighted the prejudices and the ambiguity of the fine line between gender and sexuality, and most importantly those held by the IAAF.

Gender is said to be a social construction while sex is a biological definition. As straightforward as this may seem, it is apparently not that simple. The IAAF asked Semenya to take a gender test, despite the fact that she was born female and raised as a woman (this is according to both her mother and her South African birth certificate), as this does not automatically qualify her to be a female in their standards. Let us note that they do have a set of conditionalities- biological, which determine where one falls in the gender category. Presumably Semenya and her family's conviction about her feminity are based on those simplistic social characteristics that we demand from everyone primarily the genital location of the person not just appearance. But the IAAF wanted an investigation seeking to go beyond these social requirements, that is to find out if Semenya has unusually high levels of testosterone, even though she is a woman, which give her an additional advantage over other female competitors. Biologically this is plausible of course, but all of us know that the social implications of this question are fundamentally problematic. Apparently for strength and athletics, at the end of the day this social construction of gender and sexuality does not matter and the distinction lie in hormones.
Telegraph Sport revealed that she has three times the normal level of testosterone in her body for a female, but comprehensive results will be available after a couple of weeks.

When the races are over, she has to come back and live within her society. The tests prove that she has this hormonal imbalance so does that in our eyes make her a man? In which category would she run in the future? How should she lead her life from now on, as a man or woman? Is she supposed to slip into a dress or stick to just pants? How can we expect the family of a teenager from rural South Africa to have this biological understanding of their daughters’ anatomy, or anyone's family to conceive of such questions?

Though Athletics South Africa (ASA) has come out to defend her (and even had to go as far as begging her to go to the podium to accept the medal) one cannot help but wonder about the extent of this defense? Could they have done a better job? A
BBC article reported that the IAAF claimed that it had required the gender test three weeks prior to the event. Nonetheless, ASA did not oblige. Additionally, though it has not been established just how close the Head Coach of the South African Athletics team was working with Semenya, Telegraph Sport reported that the coach has been in the past involved in scandals regarding hormonal enhancements and doping activities. Was ASA right in hiring someone with such a past?

How can we use Semenya's personal humiliation to re-negotiate sexuality and gender? French feminist Simone de Beauvoir is famous for having declared "one is not born but becomes a woman." As an athlete Semenya is expected to be extraordinarily fit, build muscle that goes beyond those of ordinary women. In doing so, did Semenya fail to become the woman that de Beauvoir speaks of? How should women in sports distinguish themselves as athletes but still conform to our societal expectations of womanhood? Let us not also ignore the fact that this issue highlights the fascinating notion of the relation between gender and race; the core of both concepts being power. Is it a coincidence that many of the social networking groups in support of Semenya also see themselves as defending African women in particular, not just women as a group?


With the soccer World Cup in South Africa just around the corner, can South Africa really afford to be consumed by such international headlines? Alternatively, what does the behavior of the IAAF in the handling of this matter say about our international institutions in their ability to do their job without sacrificing the respect and dignity of athletes and humiliate them as it has occurred with Semenya? The power of sports lies in its ability to construct identities, form values, combat developmental challenges and bring about behavioral change. As we look forward to the World Cup, we hope that the event will help construct African identities and positive African images. We hope that Semenya (regardless of the gender results) will be a stifling force to fight gender prejudices within the sports arena and act as an opinion leader to help mitigate these social ambiguities.
»»  read more